Mass Shootings: It is a mental health problem. And it’s a gun problem.

A reporter wrote me the other day asking for a quote in the wake of the Roseburg shooting. She wanted to talk about how mental illness is being stigmatized by the NRA.

“Is it a gun problem,”  she asked, “Or a mental health problem?”

“It’s not either, or.” I answered. “It’s both.”

In Roseburg, in Springfield, in Denver, in Newtown, in a dozen or so fill-in-the-blank shootings in our country, the male shooter also had a serious mental illness.  James Holmes, Adam Lanza, Kip Kinkel, Seung-Hui Cho, Jiverly Wong, Major Nidal Hasan, Jared Laughner-ALL of these shooters had a psychiatric disorder, many of them were under the care of a psychiatrist.

Christopher Harper-Mercer, who killed nine people and wounded nine others at a rural community college in Oregon had been discharged from the Army after attempting to commit suicide, according to the Wall Street Journal and law-enforcement officials familiar with the case.

Yet, the mental health community argues, “This is not our problem,” and the public is left shaking its head.

Instead, health providers could be saying, “Yes, there is a tiny fraction of seriously disturbed young males who commit mass violence. We’d be happy to take a portion of Homeland Security funding and attempt to help!”

The NRA loves the diversion. It doesn’t actually support more funding for mental health programs and neither do the politicians who point the finger of blame at mental health providers. So, let’s be blunt: These deeply troubled men would have remained unknown to most of us, except that, they got access to a weapon, or two, or fifteen.

Meanwhile, some common sense advice doesn’t get said: If you are aware that your son, brother, or father is one of the fraction of disturbed young men who might be capable of committing an act of mass violence, hide or take away their guns. If you don’t know what a mass killer looks like, here’s a sample of the most relevant risk factors from a 2001 study of 33 mass killers: a. loner status b. substance abuse problem c. preoccupations with weapons d. victim of bullying  and e., lastly, a psychiatric history.  These risk factors are heightened by violent or aggressive behavior.  If you just said, “check, check, check” to that list, and your kid or brother or dad has access to weapons and ammunition, you’ve got a responsibility to get involved NOW.

A reader wrote me recently to say, “My son is just like the other shooters. He’s on meds. He stays in the basement all day, complaining of having no friends. He is obsessed with his guns. He plays violent video games all day long. He’s verbally abusive. I’m scared of him. What do I do?” It’s as if people are waiting for the government to wave a magic wand and help them navigate the most precarious and potentially deadly territory.

First, take the guns out of your household. It’s your home. If a friend or young adult fits this category, talk to them about their reasons for stockpiling weapons. You may be able to detect a plan they are only now sharing with the darknet. You are, sadly, the front line of defense. Call it  “a temporary gun restraining program because I love you and you’ve shown intent.” Second, attempt to get some help. Your county mental health services is the best place to begin. And for support for yourself, please learn more about NAMI.

Mental health advocates are accurate. The vast majority of people with a mental health problem will not commit an act of violence, in fact, statistically, they are much more likely to become a victim of violence or hurt themselves than the general population. But, we cannot deny that a tiny fraction of people who also happen to have a mental illness are causing a ton of heartache in our country. Nor, can we deny that if those people hadn’t had access to guns, they would not have been capable of massive slaughters.

Nobody’s coming for your guns, but it’s time to re-evaluate how accessible they are to others.

Subscribe To MyNewsletter

Subscribe To MyNewsletter

Join my mailing list to receive the latest news and updates. I promise no spam and will never share your information.

You have Successfully Subscribed!

6 replies
  1. Dan Trachsel
    Dan Trachsel says:

    This is by far the most useful and logical message so far regarding mental health and gun violence. The first step to a solution is now in our hands to do something.

    Please read this article and see if you know somebody that fits these characteristics.

    Reply
  2. James Allen Harrell
    James Allen Harrell says:

    I agree with all you say in your article except (Nor, can we deny that if those people hadn’t had access to guns, they would not have been capable of massive slaughters).
    A good example, Timothy McVeigh used fertilizer and fuel oil, on 911 they used box cutters and airplanes and the list could go on and on.
    Guns don’t kill people any more than box cutters, airplanes and fertilizer. Mentally disturbed psychotic People kill People and will use any means at their disposal. The key is to find and treat these people before they go over the edge.The people best situated to do this are those closest to the troubled person. We as a society must be willing to lock these folks up and force treatment on them if necessary. We must quit politicizing the issue and get serious about mental health starting with parents and friends of those with severely disturbed minds. JMHO

    Reply
    • Rebecca Spilger
      Rebecca Spilger says:

      James Harrell you are a jerk! I have bipolar disorder from too much stress and my plan of action is to “nap”, travel and work part time for social activity. I think people turns to guns because of all the negativity of the world, including social media, and employers just expect so much that I said Take This Job and Shove IT!! I plan to travel with my boyfriend before we get too old. I am glad I retired and not growing up in today’s world.

      Reply
  3. Rebecca Spilger
    Rebecca Spilger says:

    I think it is a society is too stressed problem! I’ll never work another job because I have bipolar disorder and very few friends. My family has passed and what’s left of my family – well they don’t share anything with me so I am very lonely and have turned to facebook to express myself and try to feel valued. The only job I can find is tutor of Accounting and Math at Kirkwood Community College here in Cedar Rapids, IA but they won’t hire me for any other position. So I guess this is the way I have to reach out.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *